Join me as I travel around Northern Colorado in search of 'NoCo's Greatest Pie.' This week, a stop at the Fort Collins legend, Totally 80's.

They've only been open six years, but Totally 80's Pizza is already one of top tourist destinations for The Choice City.

Everybody knows them, everybody loves them.

The place is always fun to visit; checking out the items, the photos, the videos, the video games. It is an 80's museum in every aspect. With the joint being so much fun to visit, the pie almost becomes secondary.

I, along with cohort Jake, decided to leave our hearts out in the car and really focus on the pizza as we visited for lunch on March 4, 2020.

We ordered one of their 14" Supremes. Supremes are a great way to taste the most popular toppings, all in one pie.

Jacob Laxen, TSM
Jacob Laxen, TSM

The guy behind the counter chatted us up as the pie baked. This guy REALLY loves pizza and pizza places. He told us of a place we should visit in Nederland. Nederland is a little too far for 'NoCo's Greatest Pie,' however.

The pizza came out as Journey's 'Anyway You Want It' video started on the TV screens.

The hand-tossed pie was baked to perfection. The toppings were plentiful and tasted great. I especially enjoyed the size of the slices- not a bunch of thin triangles, not a 'few' large triangles. They were 'Goldilocks' triangles if you will.

Jake's wife joined us for lunch; the 14" large was plenty for three people, most-likely even four, if Jake and I weren't such animals.

Google Reviews (874 of them) gives Totally 80's Pizza an average rating of 4.7 stars.

I'm going to Agree. Totally 80's is a fun place with a great pie.

My 'Pizza My Heart' Review: 4.7 Pepperonis out of 5.

Stay Gnarly, Gang.

Jacob Laxen, TSM
Jacob Laxen, TSM
Retro 102.5 logo
Enter your number to get our free mobile app

More From Retro 102.5